People claim that Jimmy Hays is the best steakhouse on Long Island, and who are we to argue with the people? If you love cheese or garlic bread, order the infamous Gorgonzola Garlic Bread appetizer. And since it IS a steakhouse, you’re pretty much obligated to order beef, like the Brontosaurus-sized porterhouse for two or the ribeye. Tip: Jimmy Hays is one of the few places on our Long Island list that you can’t roll into right off the beach; shorts, sand, and flip-flops won’t fly at this spot.
4310 Austin Blvd, Island Park NY